Crypto security, cryptographic instrument or DLT financial instrument?

Crypto security, cryptographic instrument or DLT financial instrument? A comparison of the three structuring options and what the choice means for issuance, custody, settlement and trading.

Crypto security, cryptographic instrument or DLT financial instrument?
Crypto security, cryptographic instrument or DLT financial instrument?

Anyone seeking to issue securities using distributed ledger technology (DLT) faces a fundamental choice: a crypto security under the eWpG, a cryptographic instrument or a DLT financial instrument under the DLT Pilot Regime. The choice determines not only the legal framework but the entire operating model, from issuance and custody to settlement and trading.

Key points at a glance

  • There are three structuring options for DLT-based securities: a crypto security under the eWpG, a cryptographic instrument and a DLT financial instrument under the DLT Pilot Regime.
  • For institutional investors and scaling within the EU, the crypto security is currently the most attractive model.
  • Cryptographic instruments offer greater flexibility, but neither protection of good-faith acquisition nor a uniform classification across the EU.
  • The DLT Pilot Regime is the strategic target picture, but for now remains constrained by its pilot character and by admission and volume limits.
  • The biggest operational difference concerns the register: only crypto securities require a crypto securities registrar regulated in Germany.

Three routes to digital securities

Crypto security under the eWpG. A crypto security is a MiFID II financial instrument regulated under prospectus, supervisory and civil law. It is recorded in a crypto securities register under the German Electronic Securities Act (eWpG). The structuring options are broad, including bonds (bearer bonds), funds, registered shares and structured certificates.

Cryptographic instruments. This category covers tokenised securities issued outside the eWpG under the EU Prospectus Regulation, as well as tokenised other investment rights under the German Capital Investment Act (VermAnlG). The focus is on debt, typically crowdfunding or subordinated corporate financing instruments.

DLT financial instrument under the DLTR. A MiFID II financial instrument that is issued, traded or settled on a DLT market infrastructure under the DLT Pilot Regime (Regulation (EU) 2022/858). Eligible instruments include shares, bonds, other eligible debt instruments and UCITS.

The three structuring options compared

The overview covers the definition, possible asset classes, advantages, restrictions and the potential for scaling within the EU.

Crypto security (eWpG)Cryptographic instrumentsDLT financial instrument (DLTR)
DefinitionMiFID II financial instrument regulated under prospectus/supervisory law and civil lawTokenised security (EU Prospectus Regulation)Tokenised other investment rights (VermAnlG)MiFID II financial instrument that is issued, traded or settled on a DLT market infrastructure under the DLT Pilot Regime
Possible asset classesBroad structuring options: bonds (bearer bonds), funds, registered shares, structured certificatesBroad structuring options in the area of debt, typically crowdfunding or subordinated corporate financing instruments. Other asset classes possible in principle, but often restrictedShares, bonds and other eligible debt instruments, UCITS
AdvantagesHigh legal certaintyProtection of good-faith acquisitionEstablished German legal frameworkPossibly required by DLT market infrastructures as an admission criterionGreater flexibility in designing and further developing smart contractsDirect peer-to-peer transfer without prior onboarding with a crypto securities registrarEU-wide harmonised market infrastructureEnables DLT-based trading and settlement
Drawbacks/ restrictionsPrimarily national legal regimeRegistrar requiredCross-border recognition of register effects not fully harmonisedNo protection of good-faith acquisitionLimited legal certaintyDiffering classification across EU Member StatesPilot characterAdmission and volume limits1Still a limited number of authorised DLT market infrastructures
EU scalingCurrently the most attractive model for institutional investors and scaling within the EU. Some other EU jurisdictions have (register) rules comparable to the eWpGSelectively attractive for specific asset classes and individual setups (DeFi applications)Hardly any scaling effect (on the product side)Strategic target picture for a capital market scalable across Europe
1Product and threshold limits under Art. 3 DLT Pilot Regime, incl. shares only where the issuer’s market capitalisation is below EUR 500m and bonds only where the issuance size is below EUR 1bn. The total market value per DLT market infrastructure must not exceed EUR 6bn when new instruments are admitted; once it reaches EUR 9bn, the transition strategy must be activated. Possible relaxation in future – cf. the Market Integration and Supervision Package (MISP).

What the choice means for the operating model

The biggest operational difference concerns the register: crypto securities always require a crypto securities registrar regulated in Germany, while cryptographic instruments do not. This affects all four stages of the value chain – issuance, custody, settlement and trading.

Crypto security (eWpG)Cryptographic instrumentsDLT financial instrument (DLTR)
IssuanceIssuance via a German-regulated crypto securities registrar requiredIssuance under national legislation. No crypto securities registrar requiredIssuance under national legislation combined with the requirements of the DLT Pilot Regime (common intersection)
CustodyCollective registration: safe custody business and, where applicable, qualified crypto custody business KWG-E1Individual registration: qualified crypto custody business KWG-EQualified crypto custody business KWG-EDepending on whether the asset is a crypto security or a cryptographic instrument, the respective regulatory custody requirements apply
SettlementRegistration/transfer of ownership via the crypto securities registerIf a trading venue is involved, settlement takes place in conjunction with the DLT SS or DLT TSSSettlement between two custodian banks only possible if both are participants of the register. Foreign custodian banks must have notified the custody business in Germany (passporting)Settlement by transfer (finality)If a trading venue is involved, settlement takes place in conjunction with the DLT SS or DLT TSSRegistration/transfer required in the crypto securities register for crypto securities. In addition, the DLT SS or DLT TSS performs the record-keeping. Synchronisation between the DLT SS or DLT TSS and the crypto securities registrar is requiredFor cryptographic instruments, the record-keeping of the DLT SS or DLT TSS is decisive
TradingBilateral trading (OTC) or via the DLT Pilot Regime (DLT MTF or DLT TSS)2Bilateral trading (OTC) or via the DLT Pilot Regime (DLT MTF or DLT TSS)2Trading via a licensed DLT MTF or DLT TSS
1Unless the custodian bank safeguards the keys itself
2Provided the requirements of the DLT Pilot Regime are met

Settlement is particularly demanding: if a trading venue is involved, the crypto securities register and the DLT SS or DLT TSS must be synchronised. How the crypto securities registrar, custodian bank and qualified crypto custodian work together is explained in our article The interplay of crypto securities registrar, custodian bank and qualified crypto custodian.

FAQ

What distinguishes a crypto security from a cryptographic instrument?
A crypto security is recorded in a crypto securities register under the eWpG and offers protection of good-faith acquisition and high legal certainty. Cryptographic instruments are issued under national law without a crypto securities registrar, offering greater flexibility but no protection of good-faith acquisition.

Do I need a crypto securities registrar?
Only for crypto securities under the eWpG. Issuance then always takes place via a crypto securities registrar regulated in Germany.

Which limits apply under the DLT Pilot Regime?
Eligible instruments include shares of issuers with a market capitalisation below EUR 500m and bonds with an issuance size below EUR 1bn. The total market value per DLT market infrastructure is capped at EUR 6bn when new instruments are admitted (Art. 3 DLTR). The Market Integration and Supervision Package (MISP) may relax these limits in future.

Conclusion

There is no one-size-fits-all solution. The crypto security under the eWpG offers the greatest legal certainty today and is the first choice for institutional investors. Cryptographic instruments suit specific asset classes and individual setups. The DLT Pilot Regime is the target picture for a capital market scalable across Europe.

The key is to align the chosen structure with the operating model from the outset: register management, custody licences, settlement processes and access to trading venues must all fit together.

Which structure fits your business model?

We support you in selecting and implementing the right model, from the regulatory classification to the operating model. Contact us at info@finplanet.eu.

Factsheet to download

The comparison is also available as a factsheet “DLT-based securities” (PDF) or via the "Download PDF" button below the article.

Legal sources

Related services for this article

Regulatory Readiness

We guide authorisation and licence applications as well as notifications under MiCAR, the DLT Pilot Regime, ZAG and eWpG through to approval.

Learn more